“Muslims discovered America,” says terror-linked CAIR’s Executive Director of Islamic Propaganda

6a00e00986be4d88330120a936a08b970bNihad Awad, Executive Director for  Muslim Brotherhood proxy, Council on Anti-American Islamic Relations (CAIR), who bears an uncanny resemblance to a ferret, appeared on Iqra (Saudi Arabian television) and favorably compared the values of Islam to the values of America.

MEMRI According to Hamas/Hezbollah supporter and executive director of terror-linked CAIR (Council on Anti-American Islamic Relations), “In my view, Islam and the US are twins, linked by common values. The values on which the US was founded are the same values advocated by Islam: freedom, and especially freedom of religion, freedom of speech, protection of minorities, and spreading justice among all sectors of society.”

Shoebat  Far too few people in the west do not understand the motivation behind these lies. The kicker in this clip is when Awad lends credence to the absurd notion that Columbus discovered America only after Muslims did. Stealth Islamists like Awad know Americans better than they know themselves. He knows that it’s effective to imply that America was stolen from the Indians, that it was taken from Mexicans, and that reparations for slavery should never end.

awad_nihadcair_americans_dont_know_anything

A hidden treasure and the best book written on the middle east ever – The Forgotten Ally, click for details.

Note that Awad said Islam believes in “freedom of speech” and “spreading justice”. Yet, Mohamed Morsi, President of Egypt recently signed a sharia Constitution into law and then said he wanted dialogue. Soon thereafter, a satirist was interrogated by prosecutors for speech critical of Morsi.

Awad’s CAIR (add a “o” at the end and you get “CAIRO”) is an extension of Morsi’s Brotherhood. If you want to know Awad’s agenda, watch Morsi. Again, Awad has to be far more stealthy because he’s on the frontline of the Brotherhood’s war with the west – the United States.

 In the words of Nihad Awad,” Islam is not in America to coexist but to dominate.”

As for Awad’s contention that Islam shares the same values as America’s founders, his support of Hamas belies any such notion.

From a speech Awad gave at an American University, “I used to support the PLO and I used to be President of the General Union of Palestine Students which is part of the PLO here in the U.S. But after I researched the situation, I decided to support Hamas instead of the PLO.”

Americans are in denial. Ignorance is no longer an excuse.

Share

56 comments on ““Muslims discovered America,” says terror-linked CAIR’s Executive Director of Islamic Propaganda

  1. @randy63ism: I’d like to hand you a cold Bit or a Warsteiner to rinse off the last rest of crow feathers in your throat ;-) Prost! If you visit Europe again soon, you’ll find there are still places were it looks as it used to. Two years ago, I went to a living history festival at a Roman indoor and outdoor museum in Germany. I saw only Western looking visitors. Muslims are generally not interested in getting to know European culture as you and I are. The ones who come to Munich every August come for luxury shopping and /or medical treatment . They come from places like the Emirates and are so veiled that I felt very uneasy when I first saw them. It might get worse if the mega mosque ( Center of Islam in Europe) financed by the Emir of Qatar is built. Our new party “Die Freiheit” (freedom party) is trying to prevent that by collecting signatures. You can watch videos of it on their homepage. There you will see aggressive left wingers and muslims born and raised in Germany. I need to leave now.
    Nice chatting with you, too, Randy.

  2. Oops, I might be misunderstood again! Of course I am also against the islamization of all other continents, especially USA, where I have been treated better than anywhere else.

  3. randy63ism, sorry for my misleading comment. I did not want to upset anyone that much, I just enjoy giving people a millisecond-shock and then show them right away that we think alike. For example, I tell cat lovers that a cat fur is good against rhumatic pains and when they give me this horrified look I grin and reassure them that the cat has to be wearing that fur of course, alive, warm and purring next to you. Sorry again, I’m glad you were at least still able to write an angry comment and get some steam off. I can assure you I stem from a purely Christian background and am one of numerous Germans who are against the islamization of Europe.

    • @Munich: No need for apologies my friend. Great analogy about the cat fur BTW. I love your beautiful country. I lived there from June 1991 to June 1994, at Bitburg Flugplatz in the Reinland-Pfaltz. It was a great location, about twenty kilometers north of Trier, your oldest city. I loved checking out the Roman ruins there. Many don’t realise it but Trier was an important city of the Roman Empire in it’s day. The Emperor Constantine held court there briefly before establishing Constantinople (Istanbul) as his capitol, his basilica still stands (as a Lutheren church, connected to the Catholic Archbishop of Trier’s palace, go figure. Nothing wrong with that of course, it’s a good thing.) Then there is the Dom dating back to Constantine’s reign, the bathouses, the Porta Negra, the Benedictine Monastery, the Marktplatz, the Roman Bridge spanning the Mosel River (we used to drive military convoys over that bridge. Romans were brilliant engineers weren’t they?)

      Bitburg was a great launching point for incursions into Luxemborg, France, Belgium, and the Netherlands as well. I have often wondered how much has changed there since those days and I cannot bear the thought of how a rapidly growing muslim population will permanently alter the landscape both human and structual. I fear for those priceless artifacts and historic buildings, the great cathedrals, the art within them all, for we all know the muslim propensity to hijack other cultures, claiming ownership of the accomplishments of others, destroying and disgarding that of no use to them as the Taliban did to those pre-islamic Buddha statues, and as the Egyptians recently did to that museum of antiquities, not to mention what they did with the ancient Library of Alexandria over a thousand years ago. For the sake of our Western Civilization, we all must do our level best to halt and reverse this trend, this invasion. We need better leaders unclouded by an internationalist agenda, this so-called ‘New World Order’ or whatever.

      Anyhow, it’s been nice to chat with you.

      Randy

      “Bitte ein Bit!”

  4. It is true that Muslims and Awad are a bit on the insane but remember the purpose for making this claim. The defensive doctrine of jihad states that if Muslim territory is captured by non-Muslims entities it is the duty of the Ummah to rise up and retake the land as it is Allah’s and must be inhabited by Muslims. Hizb taught the same thing a few years back in Palestine that America was first discovered by Muslims making it Muslim land. Last year I went to mosque at Steel’s corner in Ohio for a Muslim Day. The speaker argued that Muslims had discovered America first as well. It is growing theme. This is a slight of hand may seem innocuous, silly, stupid or plain ignorant but in reality this is a call for jihad.

  5. @Arjay: That was an awesome post. I live in Indian Country (N.E. Oklahoma) and my sons are Muscogee Creek from their mother’s side.

    It has always pissed me off when muslims make stupid, arrogant claims such as this fantasy discovery they supposedly made, or it’s corollary, the claim that many Tribes were muslim before Columbus. Muslims engage in cultural hijacking wherever they go. It is nothing but theft of one’s culture that fits their supremacist agenda.

  6. @BNI: Thanks for pointing out my verbal fratricide. I apologised. I thought Munich was a German of Turkish origin. We certainly don’t need friendly fire incidents. We need all hands on deck with this fight.

    Again, thanks.
    Randy

    • Randy, I have done the same thing myself and learned the hard way. I’d read the first few lines of a comment and size the person up, wrongly, because I didn’t read enough of the comment. When people aren’t regular commenters here, sometimes it’s hard to know when they are joking or not. Don’t beat yourself up about it.

  7. I just cannot get over the pack of lies this man was telling like as if we, who are informed, would really believe such hogwash. Except maybe their progressive (commie) liberal friends.

    “protection of minorities, and spreading justice among all sectors of society.”

    What about the Coptic Christians, Zoastrians, Jews, Hindus and other minorities that have been both oppressed and purged by Islam the tolerant religion????

  8. That is complete horseshit. North America was discovered by the Vikings led by Lief Erickson around circa 1050 and landed on the coast of Newfoundland Canada.

  9. I should change my username to Arnold Ziffel in order to strike terror and fear in the heart’s of the Porkaphobic hoards from the Middle East, the so-called ‘Friday People.’

    “Allahu Oinkbar!!”

  10. Munich, you are full of shit, you are a troll, and furthermore, you know it.

    1) Muslims demand freedom.

    Yea, for muslims and nobody else. In fact, muslim’s definition of freedom is highly subjective. Not at all the form advocated in the US Constitution.

    2) Freedom of speech.

    Muslims are, in fact well known for demanding blasphemy laws in Western nations in order to stiffle free speech. In summary, you lie.

    3) Protection of minorities.

    It is more accurate to say, protection racket, as in second class status for non-muslim minorities in muslim dominant states. In other words, dhimmis must pay protection money known as the jizya tax. Islam, the original mafia. Speaking of which, muslim Arabs once ruled Sicily until the Normans drove them out in the Middle ages.

    4) Justice among all sectors of society.

    Again, very subjective and dualistic. Sharia law dictates the monetary value of a muslim male is twice that of a Jewish or Christian male, and a muslim female. A polytheist is well, shit out of luck on that one. They must convert, leave, or die.

    5) They demand all that for themselves.

    Yes they do, and a whole lot more, but only for themselves. Muslims don’t demand basic rights as in everyone else, they demand special rights, and everybody else’s submission and subjegation.

    In summary Munich, You are purposely practicing taqiyya, islam’s ethics are dualistic as in how muslims treat each other, opposed to how they treat everybody else. Islam has NO Golden Rule. It never had and it never will. It simply seeks dominance.

    Munich, you are a lying bag of pig flatulence! Now take your dawa act, and shove it up your ass!
    Oh yea, one more thing Munich, regarding your so-called prophet, his name is Muhammhock, Porcine Prophet of Pigslam. (may his pork get pulled) Blasphemy is fun Munich. It is also my 1st Amendment right, and not at all compatable with islam, so get out or stay out!

    Now please excuse me while I lift my ass and fart towards Mecca!

    Pffffffffft!!

      • OMG! I’m goin’ senile! Whoa is right lol. Tell me Bonni, when one eats crow, does one have to swallow the feathers? Can I pluck the bird first? Well, I doubt crow is very halal so I’ll eat away!

        Excuse me, I have some grovelling to do.

        Munich! Oh Munich! I’m sorry I missunderstood you totally. Please forgive!

  11. It just proof’s that ISLAM is based on lies an deception, as Mohammed has given us proof in his handling of the agreements he broke.
    When they have first established the western value systems in there Islamic country’s,
    and not leaving them in droves as it is now, I might believe them.

  12. Dear BNI:

    Muslims discovered America? The islamadoodles keep bringing this up every so often. As an American Indian, I remember encountering this as far back as the ’80s and one American Indian friend of mine dealt with this view from muzslime co-workers he had during the early 1970s (when the Yom Kippur War and its aftermath was in the news). Islamadoodles were also trying to sell their anti-Israeli spew to me and my fellows- trying to claim all sorts of similarities between American Indians and Fakestinians.

    On way too many occassions this happened. Yet, I never got tired of the look of absolute shock on an islamadoodle’s face when the responses back challenged their way of thinking. Many American Indians are pro-Israel and have a special affinitiy and warmth for the Hebrew tribes in Israel and around the world. When fellow Indians replied back that they supported Israel and that they believed the historical facts that Jewish people had been in Israel for thousands of years…. the muzslims just couldn’t comprehend it.

    One islamadoodle in particular was such a pain in the ass; that I and some fellow tribals decided to “share our cultures with him”… (ooops! Sorry Bonni, I know you don’t like political correctness). Let me re-phrase that… “…tribals decided to torment the camel-fucking sleazeball.” We stacked the deck in what he would see and who he would meet when we invited him to a local pow-wow.

    For BNI readers who don’t know (especially those outside of North America); a pow wow is an American Indian cultural gathering and social get-together. There is drumming, dances, music, traders, food, etc. Some may have more traditional ceremonies or other cultural stuff happening- it all depends as pow-wows can vary.
    This particular one happened before 9/11 but after the first Gulf War.

    I brought the islamadoodle to the pow-wow and there were plenty of friends to see me and say hello! Including Merideth… a beautiful outspoken and very proud American Indian Jewess (or is that Jewish American Indian). Her Jewish mother had attended graduate school in Oklahoma and met a nice handsome Indian boy that she decided to keep. The “twitch” from doodle when he noticed Merideth’s Star-of-David necklace was rather, well- very noticable. Then Doris stopped by with her dance shawl she had finished beading and wanted to show me.

    When I, the good thoughtful friend asked her how her day was; well she just couldn’t wait and tell me! As a nurse she worked with many Jewish health professionals- who were the nicest people she’s ever met. She loved her job at a Jewish home for the aged! She LOVED IT when the elderly residents would show her postcards or photographs from grandchildren living in Israel!

    Then we walked around the pow wow area perimeter. Speaking to various folks and seeing tables, trader tents and informaiton booths of all things American Indian!

    Doodle’s eyes kept getting wider and wider. His anti-Paganism was sounding alarms as he encountered traditional spiritual people, including Elders. Traders had for sale fetishes and other items, and I answered his questions about objects he saw- feathers, staffs and other things that reflected American Indian religious beliefs.

    The muzslime’s hatred of traditional beliefs whether African animists or European-origins Paganism, is similar to what I saw that day to an izlamic reaction to traditional American Indian spirituality.

    American Indian Christianity was evident. Doodle was told about tribes whose names included the words “mission bands” which reflected their connection to Christians. Many Indian Christians and Christian organizations working with Indians were present. Don’t know if Doodle realized that Christian and Traditional natives were at the pow-wow together- and nobody was antagonistic to the other.

    The Grand Entry fascinated and I think frightened him (GOOD). The GE is where the US flag and many times flags of the different uniformed armed services are brought into the circle. The flag bearers are almost always current military or veterans. This is considered solemn and respect is immediately given during this time. As this was right after the first Gulf War… there were numerous recent combat veterans in attendance. As veterans and flags entered the pow-wow circle… then AND ONLY THEN… did the other American Indians enter.

    Modern day military personnel and veterans are considered our “warriors” of the present. Be disrespectful or attack them and there won’t be enough of you to scrape off the floor to feed coyotes… and thats just the gray haired Elder grandmothers. The status of respect for older women and grandmothers at the event puzzling to him (leave the misogynistic ‘tudes before going to a pow-wow muzslimes or our Indian gals will kick your ass).

    Also, NO BURKHAS here. Pow-wows are a place to see and be seen. Almost every American Indian woman will have a small mirror or compact to continually check their hair, beaded barettes, feather accessories, and make-up. Touching up with their cosmetics bag is almost mandatory. No way would American Indian women NOT look their best before visiting with people, buying from traders or going into the dance circle. Also, many pow-wows will have a “Pow-Wow Princess” this is a designation and sometimes a competition- and young Indian women try to look their best and covering up IS NOT happening.

    One “extra” which we did NOT “set up” was the number of private conversations going around as people interacted with another. Remember- many were recent returned 1st Gulf War veterans… who had come back from Saudi and Kuwait. We overheard PLENTY of comments about American Indians’ thoughts about izslime.

    Finally, Big G showed up (as planned) and this tall linebacker build fella walked up munching on a bag of snacks he had gotten from the concession trailer. We- two American Indians…brothers in spirit embraced! Happy to see me he stuck his snackies under and arm and removed a necklace from himself and placed it around my neck! I told Doodle that it was “traditional” to exchange gifts like this upon meets and greets.

    Merideth and Doris hadn’t given me anything, but if (he didn’t) he had noticed; I would have just said some crap about it only happening between men of the same tribal background or the like.

    Doodle was curious and actually leaned forward to see “my new necklace” which was made out of small “tusks”… as Big G told the tale of himself as a great hunter and brave who made the necklace out of the tusks/teeth of the vicious beast he slayed! He used tribal language to tell the name of the slain beast!

    It was only when Doodle was holding (TOUCHING) and examining the necklace around my neck did I “translate” into English that the animal was a wild boar (ie a piggie). At the same time Big G in his gosh darn GFN (giant friendly native) way did he offer me and Doodle some of his snacks- a big bag of pork rinds.

    Doodle bolted for the parking lot.

    The only thing not true was Doris had worked at the Jewish nursing home when she was an LPN… by the time she was an RN she hadn’t worked there for a few years. Her favorite RN shift was when she worked with mostly Jewish staff at a local hospital. The other thing was Big G’s cousin had hunted the boars, and thus I had to give the necklace back because it wasn’t Big G’s to give.

    Doodle never said more than two words to me from that day forward until he left our place of employment. He also stopped his “izlamifying” attempts with American Indians… a group of people he obviously knew nothing about.

    So keep in mind…

    The price for antacids to deal with too much Indian tacos and funnel cakes you ate at a pow wow…. $1.99

    The cost for silver and beaded earrings you bought from the pretty Choctaw girl to give to your sister for her birthday… $25

    The amount you spent on raffle tickets to win an Ojibwe design quilt that benefits an Indian school in the Dakotas… $30

    Freaking the shit out of a whack-job islamadoodle who now thinks America’s Natives are a bunch of pork eating heathens (yea, some are) at said pow-wow….

    PRICELESS.

    • Arjay, great post. I have been to several pow-wows and your descriptions were most vivid. I have taken several friends from Europe and they have just loved it. The beautiful costumes, the dancing and the incredible sense of pride in the people is a sight to behold. Hope the “Doodle” told his co-religionist what they can expect from our original Americans!

  13. When islam was founded and NOW in the United States, islam does in fact advocate the values Americans believe in: muslims demand freedom, freedom of religion, freedom of speech, protection of minorities and spreading justice among all sectors of society. They demand all that for themselves, as Mohammed did and as they still do in every country where THEY are a minority.

    • @Munich: I’m sorry for missunderstanding your comment. My sarc meter is obviously not pinging like it should. Since my warranty is expired, i’ll have to buy myself a new one on payday, lol. Again, so sorry.

      Randy

      (Hmm, crow tastes sort of like chicken! Thank God it’s not halal slaughtered.)

    • “Delusional” just BEGINS to describe what this pompous prick Awad is!!…And Nimrod was considered a “mighty hunter”,which is a damn sight more than can be said for this a–hole A-wad!!

  14. You all can imagine how the Natives see this, right?
    ‘Carpets of muslims scalps.’
    It doesn’t matter what CAIR and it’s ilk do…they’re facing on oncoming opponent that will not treat them in any way other than how islam has been treating everyone else for centuries.
    They can start packing and start leaving the Western Vivilized Nations, ALL of them…or they can dither around with their games and sooner than they think find themselves shoved onto Deportation container ships bound for somalia.
    It won’t be something handled by the courts.
    It won’t be a process tolerant of delays.
    islami are dangerous, this is a proven Fact and they will not be tolerated in their threats to Humanity.
    Humanity MUST move forward in Liberty & Freedom, NO other way is acceptable or natural for Humanity.
    islam thinks to enslave, control, and will use any and all means toward that end.
    They pride themselves on how dedicated they are.
    They jihad for ‘allah’…
    WE fight for Humanity and it’s eventual destiny as a Great People.

    They claim ridiculous things like muslims discovering The Americas…
    They demand people believe the outright lies and the Leftist dominated gov’t works to make sure people do.

    islami, you will leave, now, by your own volition or you will be rounded up and forcibly Banished into Exile after your assets and accounts are siezed and liquidated to cover your deportation costs and the reparations islam owes the Western Civilized World.
    Either way…you WILL be leaving The Western Civilized World.

    • Dear Mrs. Wilkins:

      As an American Indian… lets just say I like the way you think (I’m smiling over the carpet remark). You could also mention the whacking off of scrotums to be made into coin purses or tobacco pouches. How I see this and my Native relatives and friends see this… oooooohhhh the islamadoodles have NO IDEA what they are messing with.

      Right now there are Turk business and government leaders on a Turkish national level that seem to be “courting” tribal communities. There are also (sadly) a few Native people who “buy into” the Fakestinians being a poor “colonized people.” However, most of the American Indians I know don’t go for the izlime line. This view point will just cause the islamadoodle standing to sink even further.

      The sometimes tragic and other times amazing set of historical, cultural, economic and political changes that began when New World met Old World…. began in 1492 with Columbus. As an American Indian… whatever good or bad would befall us from that date… it was Europe that encountered us. It is descended from that interaction that today define American Indians (First Nations), Eskimo/Inuit, Chamorro (Guam natives), Metis (Canadian and US) and Native Hawaiians in the 21st century.

      We ARE PART OF THE MODERN WESTERN CIVILIZATION and are NOT, NOR WILL WE EVER BE… part of izslime world NO MATTER how much islamadoodles try to re-write history.

      Say Mrs. Wilkins… earlier this summer I slammed the muzslimes for stealing fetishes and amulets (worn by African animists) in Mali… this was in a post over at Jihad Watch. A woman replied with her support for Africans with traditional beliefs and how muzslimes also persecute pagans. Was that you?

      In 1492… Columbus sailed the ocean blue…. AND HE DID NOT ENCOUNTER ISLAMADOODLES.

      • Arjay! Well-Met!! ((HUG)) I suspect they’ve been keeping the ‘tobacco pouch’ comments aside as ‘Man-Talk’…but suffice to say, I and many others would be just fine with it. Still, their manners and respect for us of the ‘gentle sex’ is appreciated.
        No the islami have NO concept of the nightmare they have stirred up, they are arrogant and stupid in their ways…too bad, they have called down their own fate and I doubt any will shed tears for them
        I am Close to Native Ways as Husband has some Native Lineage and is tied to our local Tribe, and the Enclave and the Tribe have a relationship going back for centuries. islami do steal, and then claim such as islamic property…they have attempted such here, and learned the hard way that many on our local area know Native Works when seen. The theives were arrested and sent to Somalia a while ago stripped of all but the clothing on their backs.
        I am not Native, and am still a chil learning the ways…the tribe is however rather patient with me as I do try my best and maks my errors nothing to be embarrassed about. I am Pagan, and call Native Americans Family with affection and pride as I add my efforts in keeping the Flame alive of their culture. islam moves vs. The People…it meets an angry 6’3 Brit Brunette who sides with her Family and People to the last breath.
        The islami claims simply state that they speak Lies.
        The post you refer to might have been me, but is only vaguely familiar…possible a like-minded woman to myself?? I do not hide, I use (where-as possible) the same identity across the web. I have posted some comments at Jihadwatch, and have spoken on how islami persecute Pagans…so…??? Likely a like-minded woman. :-)

      • @Arjay,

        The problem with the thesis that Islam discovered America (and Australia). The Muslims are forgetting one fact, that there is one thing we we all know about a Crusading Islam.

        Is that once it lands somewhere, it does not leave!

        They tend to take over and seek to dominate the indigenous population.
        There is a plethora of scholarly information of the ‘Contact Period’, which is the time when, Europeans and Native American first made contact and there is absolutely nothing anywhere about Islamic ‘contact’ with Native Americans.

        Furthermore, there is archeology (contentious) evidence that demonstrates that the pre-Columbian Vikings made it all the way into the mid-west.

        Additionally, as Muslims are want to tell us frequently how advance they were, whilst we were in a Dark Age (insert snort of derision here.) There are several documents that are from the 10th century Islamic traveler, Ahmad ibn Fadlān who traveled to Russia with Vikings. (See: http://www.amazon.com/Ibn-Fadlans-Journey-Russia-Tenth-Century/dp/1558763651). There are no such documents that demonstrate a discovery of the America.

        …But, then we all know that Islam/Muslims and the truth towards Non-Muslims does not exist.

  15. BULLSHIT.
    The bullshitter generally knows his statements are weak, exaggerated or in other ways misleading but the bullshitter has NO INTEREST in their factual accuracy one way or the other.

    Mozzies are greater enemies of truth than outright liars. Most of Islam is unprovable BULLSHIT.

    Americans HATE bullshit.

  16. Lindarm,the non muslim world is insane, to believe these liars,hypocrits, Awad is right when he said ” when i speak to those people, they know nothing ”
    And since muslims now claim they discovered America, watch for demanding the right of return,like palestine and Spain.

  17. nihad awad is an outright liar who is well versed in taqiyya. The books donated to the libraries of the US should be banned. Let us find them and complain to the librarians that the information is false. The muslims did not discover America. We must out the lies at every opportunity. This interview is totally false in everything the pervert awad says. Only a simple fool or an imbecile would believe any of this false interview.

  18. And the dhimmi and Islamophilic school boards, for the most part, will implement CAIR’s “curriculum.”

    Get your kids out of the public schools! Homeschool them! Don’t let your children’s minds be ruined!

      • I prefer ‘islami’ as it’s easier to type, vaguely insulting although the muzzies have fits trying to define exactly HOW…always fun to watch them work their sub-primate brains.
        And it can be used as noun and perjorative. :-)

      • Dear BNI:

        I prefer islamadoodles (brains are wet limp noodles just like their small penises). Islami? Mmmm? Sounds somewhat “porcine” doesn’t it?

      • Arjay, my problem with Islamodoodles is that it sounds too cute, an endearment, and the last thing any muslim could ever be considered is cute. I prefer something nastier.

      • Didn’t they make that claim about discovering America before? Wasn’t it in one of their school texts? Didn’t it cause consternation among American aboriginals?

        In your top picture, he reminds me of Lenin.

Leave a Reply